top of page

The Final Fifty: When Theatre in My Backyard Bested the Broadway, a tribute to Four Theatre Companies

marcalexander88
6 days ago
5 min read

I pride myself on seeing a lot of shows. Hence this blog, amiright? That includes annual trips to New York, and several in one year when I’m really lucky. However, Broadway theatre being the best I’ve ever seen is not always true. Below are four instances where theatre in my Central Valley or Bay Area backyards caused me to look at a show in a new way: with likeability.


CenterStage Clovis Community Theatre, Bandstand

Let's start with the most recent. I saw this show in New York because I lost out on the rush for Come From Away. (Don't worry, I saw Come From Away the next night, as was explained in my first essay in this series.) Next door was Bandstand. With it being Andy Blankenbuehler's follow-up to choreographing Hamilton, we were intrigued and willing to get the last-minute rush ticket to check it out; we should've known why there were so many tickets available.


Boy, was I....disappointed. Conflicting concepts seemed to take the commercial and name-recognition aspects more seriously than honoring our veterans. The periods mixed, the musicianship seemed like a gimmick more than being celebrated, and the heart just wasn't there.


Cut to opening night of Bandstand in Clovis, CA. This show sifted through the tell-not-show, and allowed the actors to not shy away from the turmoil one may feel after coming home from war or being the widow of a fallen soldier. Every time the musical pivots from going "there" this production didn't waver; it took it on, it truly saluted the very veterans the show touts to honor; it went "there." The music is stellar--having listened to the Broadway cast recording twice now by the time of this essay's publishing--but when the heart of CenterStage Clovis Community Theatre does away with the flashiness Broadway execs. expect, the reason for this show comes through, and I'm grateful to now appreciate why this musical was written.



Ray of Light Theatre, American Psycho


Oh, just look at how excited I am. By show's end, I felt so ashamed of myself when I opted to grab a TKTS ticket for a closing week performance of this musical. I recall turning to my friend Dominic (more on him later) that night, after about the third song of a forgettable score and asking, “What. are we watching…?” He didn’t know.


I likened the score to what a sixteen-year-old, who had no good taste in music, would choose for the shift’s playlist at an H&M retail store. I remember Benjamin Walker’s abs, technical snafus with the music, and Alice Ripley in a poop-squat position on a revolving platform. Ugh!



But then I was convinced that Ray of Light Theatre’s production would be worth the ticket, and I was correctly convinced! It was fun, it was risqué, it was honoring of the film and book while still knowing exactly what it was: a pop-rock score of sorts that relies on aesthetic, pristine execution, and shimmer with not much depth. The talent went deep for this production, though, and made the material not just palette-able but, dare I say, a musical I hope to see again?



Shine! Youth Theatre, Dear Evan Hansen


Okay, the photo below is after an early morning flight, train and subway commute into the city, and a rainy day, where I had only enough time for a quick bite and pint at my favorite watering hole in Manhattan, and then jetted straight to The Music Box with my luggage still in tow. It was Tony Awards week, and I had heard of how often understudies had been going on. I just wanted to see the show and, much to my surprise, the entire original cast was in that night. I sat in my seat and was surrounded by rows of junior high students with their teachers and, it was clear by the middle of Act One, we were all true theatre kids. They behaved immaculately. So did I, until I realized what I was watching.


I remember being really, really emotional when I saw that original Broadway cast perform this show. But also being jarred at the end of Act One (a kiss, really??). And then really loving a song about a dad teaching a kid how to break in a baseball glove. But also hating the end. I remember loving the music set to one of the most blah books of a musical I’d witnessed. I even saw the film adaptation, years later, hoping Amy Adams could redeem such a story; she could not.

So when I saw Shine! Youth Theatre, I went in with an open mind and support for those who were local. And I was impressed. Without changing anything I knew from the Broadway, touring, and film productions, there was a perspective shift: it’s a show about moms. Shine! found a way to allow for the audience to see that it's not on us to empathize with or even forgive Evan, but to see how two moms deal with loving their sons in a real, hard, rough, and truly vulnerable way. I felt this shift in the opening number, and it never teetered. It was a formative experience to see and hear a show in a new way, and it was a testament to what directorial and performance-based excellence can do to a show that an audience member has already written off as unredeemable and flawed.



Selma Arts Center, SpongeBob SquarePants: the Musical


Easily the most daunting of tasks, as I recall at intermission of seeing this show on Broadway, turning around to my friends and asking, “Are you enjoying tonight’s entertainment?” which is code for, "I am not enjoying tonight’s entertainment." I quickly replied to them with, “I’m rooting for the volcano.” I have never forgiven all staff at the Palace Theater for duping me into getting in the rush line at 6AM for a 7PM curtain, and paying the rush price for such an experience. I even wore themed socks!



However, Selma Arts Center, as they’re wont to do, showed me the side of SpongeBob… I had missed. My aforementioned friend Dominic directed this piece in Selma, CA, and knew I couldn't stand this show; he expected me to not like it. I saw the production purely in support of him and my friends in the cast. And then, I leaned forward, and was intrigued. And then I was impressed. And then I was rooting for Bikini Bottom to survive, for the friends to defeat the volcano and Plankton and all who are getting in the way of believing Sandy's science!


This production stripped away the glossy pick-me quality Nickelodeon had infused into the Broadway production and simply told the story of community in a creative, intentional way. The talent and tech design from the Broadway production is undeniable--I teach that show every year to my stage craft foundations class as their final. But in person, on Broadway, the heart wasn't there, the story was outshined by Broadway polish with very little nuanced passion. Selma provided an experience that re-shaped my allegiance with SpongeBob and the whole Bikini Bottom gang; it's not just a simple show. It has depth that goes deeper than the very ocean it's set in. Thank you to Selma Arts Center, Dominic Grijalva, and company for showing this jaded audience member that this story has bubbles and bubbles of heart underneath it.



Comments


  • Twitter

©2021 by MarcGTheatre. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page